SCIENCE IN THE NEWS DAILY
Scientists Dispute Evolutionary Value of Helping Relatives
from the New York Times (Registration Required)
Why are worker ants sterile? Why do birds sometimes help their parents raise more chicks, instead of having chicks of their own? Why do bacteria explode with toxins to kill rival colonies? In 1964, the British biologist William Hamilton published a landmark paper to answer these kinds of questions. Sometimes, he argued, helping your relatives can spread your genes faster than having children of your own.
For the past 46 years, biologists have used Dr. Hamilton's theory to make sense of how animal societies evolve. They've even applied it to the evolution of our own species. But in the latest issue of the journal Nature, a team of prominent evolutionary biologists at Harvard try to demolish the theory.
The scientists argue that studies on animals since Dr. Hamilton's day have failed to support it. The scientists write that a close look at the underlying math reveals that Dr. Hamilton's theory is superfluous. "It's precisely like an ancient epicycle in the solar system," said Martin Nowak, a co-author of the paper with Edward O. Wilson and Corina Tarnita. "The world is much simpler without it."
Read more...
Science in the Media
Newspapers:
Magazines and Web Sites:
The Science-Media Intersection:
Subscribe to Our Content!
Visit our RSS Feeds page to choose among 13 customized feeds, or create a free My AmSci account to request an email notice whenever a specified author, department or discipline appears online.