The Intermolecular Shuffle
The molecules in a crystal are not in a vacuum. They are in the solid state because of intermolecular forces—variously called van der Waals, dispersion or crystal-packing forces. Easy to parameterize in approximate calculations, excruciatingly hard to compute a priori, the intermolecular forces are weakly attractive at long distances, but have a repulsive hard core. The tiny attractions add up and make the molecules condense. And, because molecules are to a degree flexible, the intermolecular forces affect distances and angles in every molecule in the crystal by a small step dance of pushing and pulling on each other. Something is gained overall—otherwise the crystal would not form. But crystallization may take place at the cost of a small change in a bond distance or an angle relative to the unencumbered gas-phase structure. There are no tugs on a molecule sailing through outer space.
These weak intermolecular forces are behind my skeptical exclamation. Let me elaborate, and then tell a story of how the very same forces that cause the substantial chemical variance in the structure of a molecule can be used to get valuable information about chemical dynamics, namely the motion of molecules in the course of reaction. Indeed, there is an anniversary to mark—it is nearly 25 years since a pair of landmark papers showed us, with astonishing clarity, that this was possible.