Computation and the Human Predicament
The Limits to Growth and the limits to computer modeling
Limits of Limits
After three immersions in The Limits to Growth, at intervals of 20 years, I feel entitled to state some opinions.
First, the book’s message is worth listening to. There are limits, and exponential growth is unsustainable. A society that measures well-being by the first derivative of GDP is asking for trouble. But I am more optimistic than the Limits authors are about our ability to deal with these issues before the world turns into the set of a Mad Max movie.
As for the mathematical model behind the book, I believe it is more a polemical tool than a scientific instrument. Forrester and the Limits group have frequently said that the graphs drawn by their computer programs should not be taken as predictions of the future, but only as indicating “dynamic tendencies” or “behavior modes.” But despite these disclaimers, Limits is full of blunt statements about the future: “If the present growth trends continue unchanged,... the limits to growth on this planet will be reached sometime in the next one hundred years.” And whether the models are supposed to be predictive or not, they are offered as an explicit guide to public policy. For example, in testimony before a congressional committee in the 1970s Forrester recommended curtailing investment in industrialization and food production as a way of slowing population growth.
It’s possible that Forrester was offering wise advice, and someday we’ll regret not taking it. But when a mathematical or scientific argument is brought forward to justify taking such a painful and troubling action, standards of rigor will surely be set very high.
In an unpublished paper on the testing of system dynamics models, Forrester and a student wrote: “The ultimate objective of validation is transferred confidence in a model’s usefulness as a basis for policy change.” That has yet to happen for World3.
- Bardi, U. 2011. The Limits to Growth Revisited. New York: Springer Verlag.
- Berlinski, D. 1976. On Systems Analysis: An Essay Concerning the Limitations of Some Mathematical Methods in the Social, Political, and Biological Sciences. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
- Cole, H. S. D., C. Freeman, M. Jahoda and K. L. R. Pavitt, eds. 1973. Models of Doom: A Critique of The Limits to Growth. New York: Universe Books.
- Edwards, P. N. 2010. A Vast Machine: Computer Models, Climate Data, and the Politics of Global Warming. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
- Forrester, J. W. 1975. Counterintuitive behavior of social systems. In Collected Papers of Jay W. Forrester. Cambridge, Mass.: Wright-Allen Press.
- Forrester, J. W., and P. M. Senge. 1978. Tests for building confidence in system dynamics models. Report D-2926-4, System Dynamics Group, Sloan School of Management, MIT.
- Hall, C. A., and J. W. Day, Jr. 2009. Revisiting The Limits to Growth after peak oil. American Scientist 97:230–237.
- Hayes, B. 1993. Computing science: Balanced on a pencil point. American Scientist 81:510–516.
- Lane, D. C. 2007. The power of the bond between cause and effect: Jay Wright Forrester and the field of system dynamics. System Dynamics Review 23:95–118.
- Meadows, D. H., D. L. Meadows, J. Randers and W. W. Behrens III. 1972. The Limits to Growth: A Report for the Club of Rome’s Project on the Predicament of Mankind. New York: Universe Books.
- Meadows, D. L., et al. 1974. Dynamics of Growth in a Finite World. Cambridge, Mass.: Wright-Allen Press.
- Meadows, D. H., D. L. Meadows and J. Randers. 1992. Beyond the Limits: Global Collapse or a Sustainable Future. London: Earthscan Publications.
- Meadows, D. H., J. Randers and D. Meadows. 2004. Limits to Growth: The 30-year Update. White River Junction, Vt.: Chelsea Green Publishing.
- Mesarovic, M., and E. Pestel. 1974. Mankind at the Turning Point: The Second Report to the Club of Rome. New York: E. P. Dutton.
- Nordhaus, W. D. 1973. World Dynamics: measurements without data. The Economic Journal 83(332):1156–1183.
- Pugh, A. L., with the assistance of P. A. Carrasco. 1983. DYNAMO User’s Manual. 6th edition. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
- Thissen, Wil. 1976. Investigations into the World3 model: The capital and resource subsystem. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics SMC-6(7):455–466.
- Turner, G. M. 2008. A comparison of The Limits to Growth with 30 years of reality. Global Environmental Change 18:397–411.