Top banner
Subscribe
MY AMERICAN SCIENTIST
LOG IN! REGISTER!
SEARCH
 
Logo

LETTERS TO THE EDITORS

Fast-Food Publication

To the Editors:

In his column “Digitizing the Coin of the Realm” (September–October), Francis L. Macrina discusses the benefits of a system of digital publication in science. All glorified advantages of such a system aside, it also has a serious demotivating effect. Online publication leads to what some call “McDonaldization,” or cheapening, of science. Nowadays, anybody can publish almost anything on a personal or group Web page. That situation inevitably erodes the distinction between a peer-reviewed paper and a self-published one. For authors to see their paper in a hard-copy, paper-bound journal gives a sense of satisfaction and personal accomplishment. Computer printouts from an online journal hardly bring the same level of these feelings. Even if online-only publications save some trees, the eventual deterioration of the quality of their contents might well outweigh the supposed blessings.

Alexander A. Berezin
McMaster University


comments powered by Disqus
 

EMAIL TO A FRIEND :


Bottom Banner